In coin collecting, “errors” means coins the Mint made wrongly: struck off-center, on the wrong blank, or with a doubled design. Some are worth far more than face value, which is also why fakes and damaged coins are often passed off as errors. This guide explains the difference between mint errors and varieties, the common types, how to tell real doubling from worthless machine doubling, and how to avoid altered coins.
An earlier version of this page described collectors’ own mistakes, such as sorting coins badly, and advised cleaning coins with a mild abrasive. That was wrong on both counts. Mint errors are made at the Mint, and you should never clean a coin; NGC says cleaning destroys most coins’ value.

Photo: “4 clipped off center error cents.jpg” by Doug coins (four off-center struck Lincoln cents), CC BY-SA 4.0, via Wikimedia Commons.
Errors vs Varieties
PCGS draws the line this way. A mint error is a one-off mistake in the minting or striking process, so no two are exactly alike. A variety comes from a difference in a die, so every coin struck by that die shares the same feature. Varieties include doubled dies, different mint mark shapes, different date sizes and missing design details.
Common Mint Errors
PCGS lists these among the mint errors it certifies:
- Off-center strikes: the blank (planchet) sat out of place between the dies, so part of the design is missing and a crescent of blank metal shows. PCGS describes the error by the percentage of blank planchet visible.
- Broadstrikes: the coin was struck outside the collar, the ring that holds it to the right diameter, so it spread wider than normal.
- Brockages: a struck coin stuck to a die and pressed into the next blank, leaving a mirror-image, sunken copy of the design.
- Rotated dies: one die turned in the press, so the two sides don’t line up. PCGS grades these only at 20 degrees or more.
- Wrong planchets: a coin struck on a blank meant for another denomination.
- Mules: a coin struck with dies that don’t belong together, such as the front of one denomination and the back of another.
Doubled Dies and Other Varieties
The best-known variety is the 1955 doubled die Lincoln cent. PCGS explains that dies were made by pressing a design into steel more than once. When this die was pressed a second time out of line, it ended up with a doubled image of the date, LIBERTY and IN GOD WE TRUST. PCGS says some 40,000 cents were struck with that die, roughly 24,000 were released, and about 5,800 to 6,000 are thought to exist today.
Other popular varieties PCGS mentions include the 1937 “three-legged” Buffalo nickel, which is missing one of the buffalo’s legs. PCGS recognizes most common varieties listed in the Red Book, plus others in specialist references.
Doubled Die or Machine Doubling?
This is the question NGC says it hears most often, and it matters because a doubled die can carry a big premium while machine doubling usually adds no value.
- A true doubled die is built into the die, so every coin from that die shows the same doubling. The second image is rounded and raised, with clear separation; NGC notes that letters show separated serifs.
- Machine doubling (also called strike, shelf or ejection doubling) happens when a loose die bounces or shifts as it strikes. It looks flat and shelf-like, it differs from coin to coin, and NGC treats it as a novelty rather than a variety.
A loupe makes the difference much easier to see; the ANA suggests 5x to 10x for examining coins.
Damage, Fakes and Altered Coins
Many “errors” sent to grading services turn out to be damage that happened after the coin left the Mint, or deliberate alterations. PCGS says it does not certify error coins that appear to be human-made instead of mint-made. Watch for:
- Copper-plated 1943 steel cents. Officially, all 1943 cents were zinc-coated steel, and the few genuine bronze ones are rare. PCGS says the crudest fakes are plated steel cents, which stick to a magnet while a real bronze cent does not. Coin World adds that a genuine bronze cent weighs about 3.11 grams, against about 2.7 grams for steel.
- Altered dates and mint marks. PCGS notes that 1948 cents have been altered so the 8 looks like a 3. NGC says altered dates leave tool marks, usually around the changed digit.
- Coins plated, recolored or damaged after they left the Mint and sold as errors. NGC treats altered color as a surface problem that rules out a numeric grade, not as an error.
Passing a magnet or scale test doesn’t prove a coin is genuine. For anything that looks valuable, have it checked by NGC, PCGS or an experienced dealer before you buy or sell. Our guide to what to look for when buying coins covers counterfeits in more detail.
How to Start Collecting Errors and Varieties
- Learn the normal coin first, so you notice what’s different.
- Check pocket change and rolls with a loupe; off-center cents and doubled-die varieties have been found in circulation.
- Buy expensive errors and varieties graded and attributed by a major service.
- Store finds carefully; see our coin storage guide. For what drives value, see valuable U.S. coins.
FAQ
Is every off-center coin valuable?
Not necessarily. Value depends on the coin type, how far off-center it is, whether the date still shows, and its condition. Check auction records for similar coins before you assume a price.
My coin’s lettering looks doubled. Is it a doubled die?
Most likely it is machine doubling. Compare it with photos of known doubled-die varieties; a real one shows rounded, separated doubling, not a flat shelf.
Should I clean an error coin to see it better?
No. Cleaning lowers value and can lead to a “Details” grade. Use a loupe and good light instead.
Sources
- Varieties vs Mint Errors: What’s the Difference? (PCGS)
- Errors & Varieties: Seeing Double (PCGS)
- Doubled Dies vs. Machine Doubling (NGC article, excerpted in The E-Sylum)
- The 1943 Copper Cent: A Much-Discussed Rarity (PCGS)
- Testing a 1943 ‘bronze’ cent (Coin World)
- Counterfeit Detection (NGC)
- NGC Details Grading (NGC)
- Myths About Coin Collecting (NGC)
- Basics Every Coin Collector Should Know (American Numismatic Association)
This is general information for hobby collectors, not an authentication. Only an expert examination can confirm that an error or variety is genuine.

One comment
Comments are closed.